The cottage pie goes way back. We think we’ve made it clear that no, they’re not the same thing. Traditionally shepherds pie is made with ground lamb, whereas cottage pie is made with minced beef. Yes you do put cheese on top of a cottage pie. What is the difference between Cottage Pie and Shepherds Pie - trivia question /questions answer / answers. These days, both Shepherd’s Pie and Cottage Pie are usually topped with mashed potatoes. Shepherd's Pie is basically beef stew in a casserole dish, topped w/ mashed potatoes spread over the top and sealed on teh edges. A classic shepherd’s pie features lamb or mutton, with onion, carrots and peas, that is covered in homemade mashed potatoes. Twice Baked Potato Beef Shepherd's Pie… Shepherds pie is made with minced lamb. 1 decade ago. Hey, it makes sense. I believe this is because Americans tend to eat a lot less lamb compared to other parts of the world and when I asked our American readers many had never heard of a cottage pie. You distinctly note that shepherd’s pie uses lamb and that cottage pie uses beef. You write a three-page article about the difference between shepherd’s pie and cottage pie. (Other than one being in a rectangular dish and the other in a round dish). Perfect for St Patrick’s Day or a meal any night of the week. Originally, “cottage pie” referred to a pie made with any kind of meat and mashed potato. Because the focus of a cottage pie is a poor man’s dinner, the idea is that you use whatever ingredients you have in to bulk it up. However, find results from food bloggers based in the UK and Australia and it will always be an authentic lamb recipe. Even though the cottage pie is most common with minced beef, its not the only meat that is used. As we said, simply add cheese and breadcrumbs to the topping of your Cottage Pie or Shepherd’s Pie and grill until golden. Both topped with mashed potato. So, we guess a meat-free Cottage Pie would be a “cottageless pie” – but we’re bordering on the ridiculous now! For more fun facts about shepherd’s pie read this article by Jamie Oliver called 10 things you didn’t know about shepherd’s pie. eval(ez_write_tag([[580,400],'britishgrubhub_com-box-4','ezslot_6',112,'0','0'])); Not only are there differences between Shepherd’s Pie and Cottage Pie, but there’s actually a third lesser-known British pie that comes into the equation (but we’ll get to that later, along with awesome recipes for all three). 0 1. It was from a fellow food blogger that was in her 70’s, ranting with foul language and a racist slur about how horrible British people were, I decided to see what she was complaining about. Nowadays people make their own versions of both, so no matter how you refer to this almost everyone will know what you’re talking about. I think Cottage Pie has a top and bottom crust, like a Chicken Pot Pie, but w/ beef or lamb or both. To become a Cumberland pie the pie is made as usual and then topped with breadcrumbs. There is also another delicious British pie to consider and that is the Cumberland pie. Linus Upp. The difference between cottage pie and shepherd's pie is the meat. Again, it really is a mystery as to why we use the word ‘pie’ in Britain to name dishes with mashed potato toppings, as well as pastry encased fillings. In the past, there was no difference between these two names, and they were used as synonyms. Roasted Cauliflower. Plus, a bunch of great recipes from across the internet! Both dishes have mashed … As for which is the best-do you prefer lamb or beef? But more interestingly, many of them had never eaten lamb before. Originally, a pie made with any kind of meat and mashed potato was called a cottage pie. Christmas Dinner vs Sunday Roast – What’s The Difference? That’s it. Where to eat the best Fish and Chips in London and beyond…. An authentic shepherd’s pie is ALWAYS made with lamb and NEVER made with beef. So, you could take a cottage pie, add breadcrumbs over the mash and you have Cumberland. I’ve seen even the most manly and diehard meat-eaters shy away from eating lamb, not because of … 1.3 3. Technically shepherd’s pie is traditionally made with lamb while cottage pie is made with ground beef. Poor families that lived in cottages (hence the name cottage pie) started eating meat loaded with mashed potatoes. 9 Answers. I freeze it all the time as you can see here. And mushrooms, of course. What is the difference between shepherds pie and cottage pie? … Shepherd’s Pie uses lamb mince (as you might’ve already guessed from the name) whereas Cottage Pie is a beef mince based dish. So this recipe should probably be named cottage pie since it does not contain lamb. All we know is that it’s a bloody good addition! Traditionally and still by many UK northerners, Shepard's pie is made with a layer of mashed potato on top of the lamb mince. Similar to the cheese saga (yep, we’re really calling it a saga), we say, just enjoy your pie with the ingredients you like. It would also be filled with whatever other ingredients they had in, to make a hearty family dinner. What is the difference between cottage pie and shepherd’s pie? Here in the States, we make it with beef and call it shepherd’s pie regardless. It was what shepherd ate after tending to their sheep, hence the name shepherd’s pie. Let’s start with the big difference, shall we? The best cheese to put on top of a cottage pie is Cheddar Cheese. Ok, so that doesn’t really explain why the word ‘pie’ is used when there’s no pastry, but at least it explains the ‘cottage’ part. As for which meat-free substitute you would use in place of the lamb or beef, there’s no standard choice. instant pot cottage pie vs shepherds pie Cottage Pie Vs Shepherd’s Pie “Shepherd’s pie” is made from lamb (hence “shepherd”), while “cottage pie” is made with beef. This post includes affiliate links, and we earn a small commission if you purchase through these links. This Post Contains Affiliate Links. Learn the difference between cottage pie and shepherd’s pie in this guide. Some people are sticklers for the difference, but most people just call either version Shepherd’s Pie. In summary you will not find the following ingredients in an authentic shepherd’s pie: You’ll be pleased to know that we have recipes for both. Source(s): from the oldies. 2 0. One such 'pie' is a Cumberland Pie, but just why is a Cumberland Pie any different, you may ask, given it looks almost the same as a Cottage Pie or Shepherd's Pie. She was complaining because her shepherd’s pie recipe (which on so many counts was not authentic) had received a couple of comments from British people. Vegetarians and vegans have been known to call a meat-free Shepherd’s Pie a “shepherdless” pie. The main difference between shepherd pie and cottage pie is in the meat; shepherd pie contains lamb while cottage pie contains beef. But one thing’s clear to us at the British Grub Hub, there’s absolutely a difference between Shepherd’s Pie and Cottage Pie. The addition of vegetables to the meat makes a hearty meal. Both shepherd pie and cottage pie are two types of meat pies that contain a layer of mashed potatoes on the top. First, the answer to the big question, is that the main difference between Shepherd’s Pie and Cottage Pie is in the meat. Answer Save. 1.1 1. Minted Peas. Please note that we've linked to these products purely because we recommend them and they are from companies that we trust. In modern British English, the dish is usually called “cottage pie” if it is made with beef. We love cooking with our huge collection of kitchen gadgets. Shepherd’s pie should only be named as such if it contains lamb, and “cottage” usually applies to one made with beef. … The history of cottage pie. Cottage Pie Vs Shepherd’s Pie. eval(ez_write_tag([[468,60],'britishgrubhub_com-box-3','ezslot_4',142,'0','0'])); Can’t see much difference from the pictures?eval(ez_write_tag([[728,90],'britishgrubhub_com-medrectangle-3','ezslot_8',110,'0','0'])); Us neither! Fun Trivia. 10 years ago. First, the answer to the big question, is that the main difference between Shepherd’s Pie and Cottage Pie is in the meat. Shepherd’s Pie vs Cottage Pie – What’s The Difference? Well, that’d be a less well known but arguably even tastier dish, called the Cumberland Pie…. Is Your Shepherd’s Pie Runny? If you Google shepherd’s pie you will find many, many American recipes that use beef. Below are some of the differences, similarities, and some background. Topping the mashed potatoes of a Cottage Pie with breadcrumbs and cheese actually turns your dish into what we call a Cumberland Pie.eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'britishgrubhub_com-leader-3','ezslot_3',134,'0','0'])); Here’s a couple of our favourite recipes…, Traditional Shepherd’s Pie recipeVegan Shepherd’s Pie recipe, Now, here’s a couple of our fave Cottage Pie recipes…, Cottage Pie recipeMeat-free ‘Allotment’ Cottage Pie recipe. Others say neither. As far as we know, there’s no rules as to the shape of the ovenware that should be used to make either dish. Again, adding cheese to your Cottage Pie topping is definitely a move worth making, but not necessarily a traditional one.eval(ez_write_tag([[250,250],'britishgrubhub_com-mobile-leaderboard-1','ezslot_11',131,'0','0']));eval(ez_write_tag([[250,250],'britishgrubhub_com-mobile-leaderboard-1','ezslot_12',131,'0','1'])); We can’t imagine the original recipes of either dish would’ve included cheese, but rather that this was added by some genius more recently and the trend understandably stuck! 1.6 6. Yes with a capital Y! Sections Homepage Trivia Quizzes Free Trivia Questions Player Quiz Lists Ask FunTrivia - Get Answers to Questions Daily and Hourly Trivia Games Crossword Puzzles FunTrivia Discussions Forums Trivia Chat Trivia Questions Archive. Plus let me share with you, recipes for cottage pie and recipes for shepherd’s pie. How Much Does A Full English Breakfast Cost? Plus, don’t forget to subscribe below to join our email newsletter with updates of our latest recipes, latest freebies, our cooking stories, plus much more: Google shepherd’s pie and you will see that most results are cottage pie with strange ingredients like sweetcorn and runner beans. Shepherd’s pie … It’s basically the same dish but cottage pie uses beef mince and shepherds pie uses lamb mince. The name “shepherds pie” does not appear to be old, first appearing in the 19th Century, although the dish itself must be … The only real difference between the two is the meat. Both Shepherd’s Pie and Cottage Pie are incredible traditional British dishes. Welsh Rarebit vs Cheese On Toast – What’s The Difference? Or both being available in freezer meals or your grandma apologising that we had to stick with cottage pie because she couldn’t get to the butchers for shepherd’s pie ingredients. But while British folks may be fine with lamb, not many Americans are. Shepherd’s pie should only contain lamb, and cottage pie usually applies to one made with beef. I always wondered what the difference was between Shepherd Pie vs Cottage Pie and how the two options became so interchangeable here in the States. (and How To Make The Best), What Does Haggis Taste Like? Learn the difference between cottage pie and shepherd’s pie in this guide. The main difference between cottage pie and shepherds pie is the meat that is used. Shepherds deal with sheep, therefore Shepherd’s pie better have lamb in it. Enter Cottage Pie! Then there’s the camp who say chuck both in! In comparison the shepherd’s pie was the upmarket version of the cottage pie. eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'britishgrubhub_com-large-mobile-banner-1','ezslot_0',124,'0','0'])); Back in the day, potatoes were an affordable crop even for the peasants of Britain. However, both were often used as a way of hiding truly … Both consist of a meat base covered in a potato top crust. Traditionally cottage pie is made with beef and shepherds pie is made with lamb. The ingredients are pretty much the same, but a shepherds pie contains lamb, while cottage pie contains beef. But that’s not all…eval(ez_write_tag([[336,280],'britishgrubhub_com-large-leaderboard-2','ezslot_14',114,'0','0'])); Shepherd’s Pie is understood to originate from Ireland (although enjoyed across all of Britain and other parts of the world with any sense!). Today it is usually called “cottage pie” if it is made with ground beef and “shepherd’s pie” when it’s made with minced lamb because a shepherd looks after sheep. When it comes to Shepherds Pie vs Cottage Pie, here’s some more common questions we usually face…. The straightforward difference between shepherd’s pie and cottage pie is that the former is made with lamb, while the latter is made with beef and/or other ground meats. What is Shepherds Pie? In this version of Cottage Pie we use fresh minced beef, however you can also use leftover Roast Beef. the minced meat, it just doesn’t seem right to use the two names interchangeably.eval(ez_write_tag([[336,280],'britishgrubhub_com-mobile-leaderboard-2','ezslot_13',121,'0','0'])); Some would argue, including many Brits, that Shepherd’s Pie or Cottage Pie are in fact not pies at all. If it is made with lamb, it is usually called “shepherd’s pie” (because a shepherd looks after sheep). if you feel like making a shepherds pie then just swap the beef for lamb and tada you got an ultimate shepherd’s pie. Favourite answer. Even so, with the core of each dish being entirely different, i.e. There is a difference between the two dishes; Shepherds pie is an Irish dish that contains lamb or even mutton. 1.5 5. Originating from sheep country in Scotland and northern England, shepherd's pie is made with minced lamb or mutton – traditionally roast left over from the day before – and covered with mashed potato, although in Scotland it can be topped with pastry. In fact, the cottage pie was invented before the shepherd’s pie. And Cottage Pie is an English dish that has beef. But, it’s pretty clear to us that both Shepherd’s Pie and Cottage Pie (and Cumberland Pie) are among the best pies in the world. I grew up in northern England and cottage pie, shepherd’s pie and Cumberland pie are served to you on a regular basis. The only real difference between the two is that “Shepherd’s pie” originally was made with ground lamb (hence “shepherd”) Cottage pie is traditionally made with beef. The difference between Cottage pie and Shepherd's pie is that cottage is beef and shepherd's is mutton. eval(ez_write_tag([[250,250],'britishgrubhub_com-leader-4','ezslot_9',122,'0','0'])); It’s probably most Brits’ view (despite loving both Shepherd’s Pie and Cottage Pie) that a ‘proper’ pie is encased with some form of pastry, such as the famous British dishes that are Pie and Mash and Apple Pie. Bon-Appetite. Cottage pie has cottages in it, or beef. I also do 50% potato and 50% swede sometimes. Even at the home of great British food, we almost feel like we could be committing a crime by adding cheese to our Shepherd’s Pie. Cottage pie is made with minced beef. What is the difference between shepherds pie and cottage pie? Cumberland pie can be any meat though and have any add ins you like. But they did point out that her recipe was a cottage pie recipe not shepherd’s pie. You put beef as the meat in shepherd’s pie! It begs the questions, why is Cottage Pie called a pie and equally, why is Shepherd’s Pie called a pie? We’re rebels like that! However, false it may be, the terms having been used interchangeably in antiquity, it has becomes todays truth. Hello, we’re the Milner’s and we run Recipe This from our home in the Algarve in Southern Portugal. So, when a nasty Facebook update showed up in my newsfeed in early 2016, I was rather shocked. Cottage Pie and Shepherd's Pie are very similar. So, this week with us sharing with you how to make both an instant pot cottage pie and an instant pot shepherd’s pie, I thought it would be the perfect time to show the history and differences between cottage pie and shepherd’s pie. Either would be a great choice to eat for lunch or dinner, any day of the week. What is the difference between cottage pie and shepards pie? Basically shepherds look after sheep, hence a lamb or mutton pie is called a shepherds’ pie (but not shepherd’s pie if you want to be pedantic)… Any British beef and mashed potato pie is called a cottage pie. Shepherd’s Pie is traditionally made with ground lamb while it’s more well-known and oft-mistaken cousin, Cottage Pie, is made with ground beef. I find the original recipe a bit bland, so I add a whole pepper (red or green chopped), garlic and Tabasco sauce with Worcestershire sauce. It is also popular to load up the cottage pie with sweetcorn and sometimes other vegetables too. It’s no wonder these two, very similar, dishes are often confused. There is no additional cost to you if you purchase through one of our links. (and Answers to 23 more Haggis-related questions!). However, since the original meat pie with potato topping was first named in the late 1790s, around the introduction of potatoes to Ireland, when workers lived in “cottages,” the lines have blurred. The idea being is that with potatoes first being a thing in the UK that they could be used for a cheap family dinner. This Is Probably Why…, The Best British Snacks – 100+ UK Crisps, Cakes, Biscuits, Chocolate Bars and Sweets, How To Cook a Roast Dinner For 10 Or More People…. 1 What To Serve With Cottage Pie. It’s actually been said that Cottage Pie was historically used to name any pie containing meat and mashed potatoes. And yes, this is beef. Can you freeze shepherd’s pie? Some people say no peas. Roasted Asparagus With Garlic. Then a cottage pie is the version that is made with beef. A pub meal in England would not be the same without seeing both cottage pie and shepherd’s pie on the menu. But what’s the difference? 2 2. And then after all of that you get to the bottom and put in your own recipe for shepherd’s pie and I read it and what do I see? Shepherd’s Pie uses lamb mince (as you might’ve already guessed from the name) whereas Cottage Pie is a beef mince based dish. These peasants usually lived in cottages. Cottage Pie Vs Shepherd’s Pie. Just don’t call it a Cottage Pie if you’re using lamb, or Shepherd’s Pie if you herd cows, for goodness sake! Some say no carrots. Facebook Group | Pinterest | Twitter | YouTube. This is of course folk wisdom and bears no examination. What is the difference between shepherd’s pie and cottage pie? Anonymous. All three are much the same thing but in the first two, the meats vary; in a shepherd's pie, the meat is lamb (there is a …